Two Developments, Two Different Measures of Bank Risk
Kuwait's Boubyan Bank has completed a $500 million Additional Tier 1 (AT1) sukuk issuance carrying a 7.375% profit rate, while S&P Global Ratings has assigned the bank a BBB+ rating under its new framework for assessing creditworthiness without extraordinary government support.
The two developments, disclosed within days of each other, offer a useful perspective on the relationship between bank credit ratings, regulatory capital and investor risk appetite. Boubyan's existing S&P issuer rating remains A, two notches above its newly assigned BBB+ Bank Rating Excluding Government Support (RXG). The new rating does not represent a downgrade, nor does it replace the bank's existing issuer credit rating.
The sukuk, meanwhile, attracted orders exceeding $1.1 billion, more than 2.2 times the issue size. It was priced on 12 November and settled on 19 November 2026, with the bank reporting successful completion of the transaction. The certificates are perpetual, with the first call date scheduled for 19 November 2031.
Taken together, these developments raise a relevant question for bank creditors and investors: how should the financial strength of an institution be assessed when its conventional issuer rating incorporates potential external support, while holders of its AT1 instruments assume substantially different contractual and loss-absorption risks?
The answer requires separating three considerations: the bank's own financial condition, the potential availability of extraordinary support and the specific position of AT1 investors within the capital structure.
What S&P's BBB+ Rating Actually Measures
S&P's newly introduced RXG framework assesses a bank's creditworthiness without incorporating extraordinary government support. The methodology, published in October 2026, was developed in connection with the implementation of elements of the Basel III capital framework.
For Boubyan, S&P assigned a long-term RXG of BBB+, consistent with the bank's reported standalone credit profile of bbb+. Its existing A issuer rating remains unchanged. The two-notch difference is analytically relevant, but it should not automatically be interpreted as a precise, two-notch measure of expected government intervention. The available disclosures do not fully separate the possible contributions of government and group support to the conventional issuer rating.
Boubyan is part of the National Bank of Kuwait group, an important consideration when assessing the broader support environment. Fitch Ratings, which affirmed Boubyan's A issuer rating with a Stable Outlook on 16 November, also recognises the potential for support from Kuwaiti authorities and the bank's parent. Fitch separately assesses Boubyan's viability at bbb-, using its own methodology.
The S&P and Fitch standalone measures are not directly interchangeable. Their differences reflect agency-specific methodologies, assumptions and rating definitions, rather than necessarily contradictory assessments of the bank's financial condition.
|
Credit assessment |
Rating |
Interpretation |
|
Moody's issuer rating |
A2 |
Bank rating reported in Boubyan's disclosure |
|
S&P issuer credit rating |
A |
Existing rating, unchanged |
|
S&P RXG |
BBB+ |
Excludes extraordinary government support |
|
Fitch issuer default rating |
A / Stable |
Incorporates potential external support |
|
Fitch Viability Rating |
bbb- |
Fitch's assessment of intrinsic financial strength |
Sources: Boubyan Bank disclosures, S&P Global Ratings and Fitch Ratings. Ratings from different agencies are presented for context and should not be treated as methodologically identical.
The broader significance of the RXG framework extends beyond Boubyan. It provides investors with an additional reference point for evaluating banks in jurisdictions where sovereign or parental support assumptions can materially influence conventional credit ratings.
For creditors, the distinction is particularly relevant when assessing instruments whose contractual terms may limit the protection available from external support arrangements.
A $500 Million AT1 Sukuk at 7.375%
Boubyan's latest capital transaction was executed through Boubyan Tier 1 Sukuk III Limited, with Boubyan Bank acting as obligor. The perpetual Mudarabah sukuk carries a fixed profit rate of 7.375%, with the first call date five years after settlement.
The transaction attracted demand exceeding $1.1 billion and was supported by an international syndicate led by HSBC and Standard Chartered Bank as joint global coordinators. The sukuk itself was not assigned a credit rating, an important distinction from the bank's issuer ratings.
|
Transaction detail |
Terms |
|
Issuer |
Boubyan Tier 1 Sukuk III Limited |
|
Obligor |
Boubyan Bank |
|
Instrument |
Perpetual AT1 Mudarabah sukuk |
|
Issue size |
USD 500 million |
|
Profit rate |
7.375% |
|
Pricing date |
12 November 2026 |
|
Settlement date |
19 November 2026 |
|
First call date |
19 November 2031 |
|
Reported investor orders |
More than USD 1.1 billion |
|
Oversubscription |
More than 2.2 times |
|
Instrument credit rating |
Unrated |
Sources: Boubyan Bank's Boursa Kuwait disclosures and transaction reporting.
At the stated profit rate, the $500 million issuance implies approximately $36.9 million in annual distributions, assuming the full principal remains outstanding and distributions are made at the stated rate. This is an indicative calculation, not an accounting estimate of the bank's total financing costs or an assessment of future distributions.
The issue was priced from initial guidance around 7.875%, indicating that investor demand enabled the bank to tighten pricing during bookbuilding. However, a book exceeding twice the issue size does not establish that the instrument was inexpensive. The appropriate assessment requires consideration of prevailing benchmark yields, the instrument's subordination and loss-absorption features, and pricing for comparable AT1 securities.
Unlike senior unsecured debt, AT1 capital is designed to absorb losses and strengthen a bank's regulatory capital position. Its perpetual nature, distribution provisions and potential principal loss mechanisms expose investors to risks that cannot be captured by the issuer's senior credit rating alone.
Accordingly, the 7.375% profit rate should not be interpreted as a direct market-implied yield for Boubyan's ordinary senior debt or as a standalone measure of the probability of bank default.
The Refinancing Detail Changes the Capital Story
One of the more important aspects of Boubyan's transaction is its relationship with the bank's previous AT1 issuance.
On 1 October 2026, Boubyan successfully called $500 million of perpetual AT1 sukuk originally issued in April 2021. The new November transaction was completed for the same nominal amount, following regulatory approvals obtained earlier in the autumn.
The previous instrument carried a reported profit rate of 3.95%, compared with 7.375% on the new issuance. The difference amounts to 342.5 basis points, or approximately $17.1 million in additional annual distributions on an equivalent $500 million principal amount, assuming the stated rates are comparable and distributions are made.
|
AT1 comparison |
Previous issuance |
November 2026 issuance |
|
Nominal principal |
USD 500m |
USD 500m |
|
Profit rate |
3.950% |
7.375% |
|
Indicative annual distributions |
USD 19.75m |
USD 36.875m |
|
Status |
Called on 1 October 2026 |
Settled on 19 November 2026 |
Indicative calculations based on stated profit rates and nominal principal. The comparison does not adjust for changes in benchmark rates, instrument terms, accounting treatment or the timing gap between redemption and settlement.
This refinancing context is essential. Although the new sukuk supports Boubyan's AT1 capital position, it should not be described as an uncomplicated $500 million increase in regulatory capital. The bank had already redeemed an AT1 instrument of equivalent nominal size, and the net effect on its capital ratios must be assessed through the relevant reporting dates and regulatory capital disclosures.
The higher profit rate also illustrates the change in the economics of replacing long-term loss-absorbing capital. It does not, by itself, establish a deterioration in Boubyan's creditworthiness. Market interest rates, investor return requirements and differences in transaction terms can all influence refinancing costs.
Nevertheless, the additional distribution burden is economically relevant when considering the long-term cost of maintaining regulatory capital buffers.
Boubyan's Financial Position Provides Important Context
Boubyan's nine-month 2026 financial results offer a more balanced picture than the rating differential or AT1 pricing alone.
According to its October investor presentation, the bank reported a non-performing financing ratio of 0.9%, down from 1.0% in the comparable period. Its return on average equity was 10.4%, while the cost-to-income ratio improved to 47.5% from 49.1%. The total capital adequacy ratio stood at 15.4%, compared with 16.4% in the prior-year period.
|
Financial indicator |
9M 2026 |
9M 2025 |
|
Return on average equity |
10.4% |
10.5% |
|
Return on average assets |
1.0% |
1.1% |
|
Cost-to-income ratio |
47.5% |
49.1% |
|
Non-performing financing ratio |
0.9% |
1.0% |
|
Total capital adequacy ratio |
15.4% |
16.4% |
Source: Boubyan Bank, 9M 2026 Investor Presentation.
The figures indicate relatively low reported non-performing financing and improving operating efficiency, although profitability measures were broadly stable. The decline in the total capital adequacy ratio deserves monitoring, particularly alongside financing growth and the bank's capital distribution and refinancing decisions.
Fitch reported Boubyan's Common Equity Tier 1 ratio at 12.8% at the end of September 2026 and identified capitalisation as a relevant consideration in its assessment of the bank's viability. The distinction between CET1 and AT1 is important here: issuing AT1 capital supports the broader regulatory capital structure but does not directly increase CET1, which represents the bank's highest-quality loss-absorbing capital.
Boubyan's financial profile therefore does not support a simplistic interpretation that a BBB+ standalone assessment signals financial distress. Equally, its investment-grade issuer ratings and successful AT1 placement should not remove the need to monitor capital generation, financing growth and concentration risk.
What the Rating and Sukuk Tell Investors
Boubyan's two recent announcements illustrate different dimensions of bank credit risk.
The S&P RXG provides a clearer view of creditworthiness when extraordinary government support is excluded. The AT1 transaction demonstrates the bank's ability to access international capital markets, while also establishing the current price of replacing a substantial tranche of loss-absorbing capital.
Neither development should be assessed in isolation. The bank's existing A issuer rating reflects a broader credit assessment than the RXG, while the 7.375% AT1 profit rate compensates investors for risks that are materially different from those associated with senior bank obligations.
For banking analysts and credit risk professionals, the more useful questions concern the sustainability of internal capital generation, the cost of maintaining regulatory buffers, the trajectory of risk-weighted assets and the extent to which financing growth can be supported without placing additional pressure on core capital.
The refinancing comparison also deserves attention across the GCC banking sector. Banks that issued AT1 instruments during periods of significantly lower financing costs may face higher distribution expenses when replacing those instruments, even if their underlying credit quality remains stable.
Boubyan has demonstrated access to investors willing to commit more than twice the amount offered. At the same time, the new instrument carries a substantially higher profit rate than the AT1 sukuk redeemed in October.
The most revealing aspect of Boubyan's latest developments is not the difference between A and BBB+, nor the 7.375% AT1 rate in isolation. It is the combination of a separately identified standalone credit profile, continued market access and a materially higher cost of replacing loss-absorbing capital.
That combination provides a more informative assessment of the bank's capital position than either announcement considered on its own.
Editorial Disclaimer
This article is based on publicly available regulatory disclosures, financial information and credit rating agency methodologies as at 22 November 2026. Credit ratings are opinions issued under the respective agencies' methodologies and are not guarantees of financial performance or repayment.
The comparisons of AT1 distribution rates are indicative and do not constitute an assessment of the fair value of the instruments or their complete contractual risk characteristics. No allegation of financial distress, misconduct or regulatory non-compliance is made.
This publication provides independent financial analysis and does not constitute investment advice. As at the publication date, the author holds no direct or indirect financial interests in the banks discussed in this article.
Sources and References
1. S&P Global Ratings, October 2026. Bank Ratings Excluding Government Support Methodology.
https://www.spglobal.com/ratings/en/products/rxg
2. Boubyan Bank / Boursa Kuwait, 22 November 2026. Disclosure of the S&P BBB+ Bank Rating Excluding Government Support, as reported by The Edge.
https://edgeconsultancykw.com/sp-assigns-boubyan-bank-bbb-plus-rxg-rating-sets-aside-extraordinary-government-support/
3. Boubyan Bank / Boursa Kuwait, 19 November 2026. Disclosure of the completed $500 million AT1 sukuk issuance and settlement, as detailed by The Edge.
https://edgeconsultancykw.com/boubyan-bank-500m-perpetual-at1-sukuk-settled/
4. Boubyan Bank / Boursa Kuwait, 4 October 2026. Supplementary disclosure confirming redemption of the previous $500 million AT1 sukuk on 1 October 2026.
https://ifsahdocs.boursakuwait.com.kw/DiscAssets/2026_19326/109%20Supplementary%20Disclosure%2004%2010%202026.pdf
5. Boubyan Bank, 22 October 2026. 9M 2026 Investor Presentation.
https://www.bankboubyan.com/media/filer_public/04/d4/04d4c284-8344-4e1a-bd8a-a8b85ed329e0/2026.pdf
6. ZAWYA, 13 November 2026. Kuwait's Boubyan Bank Prices $500mln 5.5-Year AT1 Sukuk.
https://www.zawya.com/en/economy/kuwaits-boubyan-bank-prices-500mln-5.5-year-at1-sukuk-2267854
7. Islamic Finance News, 20 November 2026. Boubyan Bank Settles Sukuk.
https://www.islamicfinancenews.com/boubyan-bank-settles-sukuk.html



