The US Securities and Exchange Commission has proposed assuming direct control of a comprehensive market surveillance system currently financed and operated through arrangements involving the securities industry.

Announced on 20 November, the proposal concerns a market monitoring infrastructure that has been the subject of longstanding disputes over operating costs, governance and the collection of sensitive trading information.

The system is intended to give regulators a more complete picture of trading activity across securities markets, supporting the identification and investigation of potential market manipulation and other misconduct.

Comprehensive market surveillance can be particularly important where trading activity is distributed across multiple exchanges, broker-dealers and other execution venues.

Without consolidated information, regulators may face difficulties reconstructing trading sequences or identifying connections between transactions executed through different intermediaries.

The proposal raises a fundamental question about the governance of regulatory infrastructure: whether systems serving public supervisory objectives should remain under industry-led arrangements or be brought under more direct regulatory control.

Supporters of stronger public oversight may argue that it could improve accountability and align system governance more closely with regulatory priorities.

However, the proposed change also raises questions about operating expenditure, cybersecurity, data access and the handling of confidential information.

Market participants have previously expressed concerns about the cost of maintaining comprehensive reporting arrangements and the risks associated with centralising large volumes of transaction data.

For broker-dealers and other financial institutions, any change in the governance model could have implications for reporting obligations, compliance systems and the allocation of operational responsibilities.

The SEC's announcement is a proposal rather than an implemented regulatory change.

Its eventual consequences will depend on the final governance structure, consultation process and arrangements for financing and protecting the system.

The development illustrates the growing importance of market data infrastructure as a component of financial regulation and operational risk management.